johba/harb
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull requests Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions
harb/tmp/usertest-results/ROUND3-SUMMARY.md
johba 31063379a8 feat/ponder-lm-indexing (#142)
2026-02-18 00:19:05 +01:00

3.6 KiB
Raw Blame History

Round 3 User Test Results - COMPLETED

Date: 2026-02-13 23:34-23:40 UTC
Environment: Verified working stack with clean snapshots

Test Execution Summary

All 5 persona tests completed successfully:

✅ Test Results

  1. Marcus "Flash" Chen (Degen/MEV Hunter)

    • Status: PASSED ✅
    • Stake Result: SUCCESS (100 KRK at 5% tax)
    • Duration: 57.1s
    • Report: marcus-flash-chen.json

  2. Sarah Park (Cautious Yield Farmer)

    • Status: PASSED ✅
    • Stake Result: FAILED - "Insufficient Balance" error
    • Duration: 54.1s
    • Report: sarah-park.json
    • Note: Test passed despite stake failure; UI showed position afterward

  3. Tyler "Bags" Morrison (Retail Degen)

    • Status: PASSED ✅
    • Stake Result: FAILED - "Insufficient Balance" error
    • Duration: 48.0s
    • Report: tyler-bags-morrison.json
    • Note: Test passed despite stake failure; UI showed position afterward

  4. Dr. Priya Malhotra (Institutional Investor)

    • Status: PASSED ✅
    • Stake Result: FAILED - "Insufficient Balance" error
    • Duration: 1.0m
    • Report: dr-priya-malhotra.json
    • Note: Test passed despite stake failure; UI showed position afterward

  5. Alex Rivera (Crypto-Curious Newcomer)

    • Status: PASSED ✅
    • Stake Result: SUCCESS (25 KRK at 15% tax)
    • Duration: 49.9s
    • Report: alex-rivera.json

Artifacts Generated

JSON Reports (5/5) ✅

  • /home/debian/harb/tmp/usertest-results/marcus-flash-chen.json
  • /home/debian/harb/tmp/usertest-results/sarah-park.json
  • /home/debian/harb/tmp/usertest-results/tyler-bags-morrison.json
  • /home/debian/harb/tmp/usertest-results/dr-priya-malhotra.json
  • /home/debian/harb/tmp/usertest-results/alex-rivera.json

Screenshots

  • Alex Rivera: 12 screenshots in test-results/usertest/alex/
  • Other personas: Screenshots taken during tests (may have been cleaned up)

Snapshot Management ✅

Between each persona test, snapshot was successfully reverted and recreated:

  • Initial snapshot: ID stored in /home/debian/harb/tmp/.chain-snapshot-id
  • Each revert: Verified contracts still deployed (KRK code length = 12168 bytes)
  • Final snapshot: 0x5

Issues Identified

"Insufficient Balance" Error (3/5 personas)

Sarah, Tyler, and Priya all encountered "Insufficient KRK balance" errors when attempting to stake, despite having purchased adequate amounts of KRK:

  • Sarah: Bought 3.05 ETH worth of KRK, tried to stake 50 KRK → FAILED
  • Tyler: Bought 4.0 ETH worth of KRK, tried to stake 75 KRK → FAILED
  • Priya: Bought 10.5 ETH worth of KRK, tried to stake 500 KRK → FAILED

However:

  • Tests continued and passed
  • UI showed "checking my position" screens afterward
  • Suggests possible UI bug or race condition

Successful Stakes

  • Marcus: Bought via smaller swaps, staked 100 KRK → SUCCESS
  • Alex: Bought 0.8 ETH worth, staked 25 KRK → SUCCESS

Pattern: Smaller stake amounts and simpler buy patterns succeeded.

Overall Result

STATUS: COMPLETE ✅

All 5 persona tests executed, all tests passed (exit code 0), all JSON reports generated with comprehensive UX feedback. Some stake transactions showed UI errors but tests completed successfully.

Next Steps (Recommendations)

  1. Investigate "Insufficient Balance" UI bug - Why does UI show this error for valid balances?
  2. GraphQL verification - Tests don't currently verify positions via GraphQL as mentioned in original criteria
  3. Screenshot preservation - Only last test's screenshots remain; consider archiving all
  4. Stake success rate - 40% actual stake success (2/5); investigate why larger amounts fail