Merge pull request 'chore: planner run — contract safety DONE, bottleneck shifts to E2E gate' (#1140) from chore/planner-20260323-1254 into master

This commit is contained in:
johba 2026-03-23 14:06:02 +01:00
commit 33e0a99e05
2 changed files with 56 additions and 12 deletions

View file

@ -0,0 +1,43 @@
# Planner run — 2026-03-23 12:50 UTC
## Predictions triaged
No unreviewed predictions.
## Prerequisite tree updates
- Resolved: int256 overflow patched (#1031 — closed)
- Resolved: Catch block clamping fix (#1019 — closed)
- Resolved: Floor ratchet attack defeated (#1067 — closed)
- Resolved: OptimizerV3 tested (#1054 — closed)
- Resolved: Holdout produces data (evidence/holdout/2026-03-22-issue517-adversarial-lp.json)
- Resolved: Floor ratchet 2000-trade oscillation run (#1082 — closed)
- Updated: Red-team now has 2 evidence files (new: 2026-03-23-floor-ratchet-oscillation.json)
- Updated: Contract safety objective → DONE (all 5 prerequisites resolved)
## Top 3 constraints
1. Mobile viewport coverage — blocks 8 objectives via E2E quality gate → Phase 1 chain — #1099 in-progress
2. Cross-browser matrix — blocks 8 objectives via E2E quality gate → Phase 1 chain — #1099 in-progress
3. Funnel test: landing → swap → stake — blocks 3 objectives via Conversion funnel → Phase 2 chain — #1100 backlog
## Stuck issues detected
No stuck issues detected.
## Issues created
No new issues — all top constraints already have open issues (#1099, #1100).
## Priority label changes
- Added priority: #1099 (new singular bottleneck)
- Removed priority: none (previous priority issues #1031, #1019, #1067 all closed)
## Observations
- **Major milestone**: Contract safety is DONE. All 4 remaining prerequisites (#1031, #1019, #1067, #1054) resolved since last run (run 5). The bottleneck that blocked the project for 5 consecutive planner runs has cleared.
- **Bottleneck shift**: E2E quality gate (#1099) is now the singular bottleneck. It's already in-progress. Only 2 intrinsic prerequisites remain: mobile viewport coverage and cross-browser matrix.
- **Velocity surge**: 4 contract safety prereqs resolved in ~24 hours after priority labels were applied in run 5. The priority label system is working.
- **Evidence pipeline progress**: holdout now has its first data file (new since run 5). Red-team has a second file. Evolution evidence still not committed to master.
- **#1082 closed**: Floor ratchet 2000-trade oscillation run completed, providing the data needed for the #1067 fix.
- **Unblocked cascade**: #1099, #1100, #1101 all received "Unblocked" comments on 2026-03-23 — the system detected the contract safety resolution and updated dependencies automatically.
## Deferred (in tree, not filed)
- Conversion funnel test (#1100) — blocked on #1099, will become actionable when E2E gate passes
- Analytics (#1101) — blocked on #1099
- Resources/protocol/user-test evidence — not on critical path
- Pitch deck, influencer outreach — blocked on Phase 1 completion

View file

@ -1,5 +1,5 @@
# Prerequisite Tree
<!-- Last updated: 2026-03-22 -->
<!-- Last updated: 2026-03-23 -->
## Phase 1 — Quality gate & release pipeline
@ -7,11 +7,11 @@
- [x] Core E2E test suite exists (tests/e2e/, 6 files)
- [ ] Mobile viewport coverage (#1099)
- [ ] Cross-browser matrix (#1099)
- [ ] OptimizerV3 test coverage (#1054)
- [ ] Floor ratchet attack defeated (#1067, #1082)
- [ ] int256 overflow patched (#1031)
- [x] OptimizerV3 test coverage (#1054 — closed)
- [x] Floor ratchet attack defeated (#1067, #1082 — closed)
- [x] int256 overflow patched (#1031 — closed)
- [x] Overflow guard for slots 1-7 (#997 — closed, merged 29b8f7d)
Status: BLOCKED — 5 prerequisites unresolved
Status: BLOCKED — 2 prerequisites unresolved. **CONSTRAINT** — blocks all downstream. #1099 in-progress.
### Objective: Conversion funnel verification (#1100)
- [x] Landing page exists
@ -65,19 +65,20 @@ Status: BLOCKED — prerequisite chain
## Foundation (cross-cutting)
### Objective: Contract safety
- [ ] Floor ratchet attack defeated (#1067, #1082)
- [ ] int256 overflow patched (#1031)
- [x] Floor ratchet attack defeated (#1067 — closed)
- [x] int256 overflow patched (#1031 — closed)
- [x] Overflow guard for slots 1-7 (#997 — closed, merged 29b8f7d)
- [ ] Catch block clamping fix (#1019)
- [ ] OptimizerV3 tested (#1054)
Status: BLOCKED — 4 prerequisites unresolved. **CONSTRAINT** — blocks Phase 1.
- [x] Catch block clamping fix (#1019 — closed)
- [x] OptimizerV3 tested (#1054 — closed)
Status: DONE
### Objective: Evidence pipeline
- [x] Red-team formula exists
- [x] Evolution formula exists
- [x] Red-team produces persistent evidence (evidence/red-team/2026-03-20.json)
- [x] Red-team produces persistent evidence (evidence/red-team/, 2 files)
- [x] Evolution commits via PR (#1047 — closed)
- [x] Evolution pipeline produces output (evidence/evolution/best.push3 exists)
- [x] Holdout produces data (evidence/holdout/2026-03-22-issue517-adversarial-lp.json)
- [ ] Resources/protocol formulas produce data (formulas exist, evidence dirs empty)
- [ ] Holdout/user-test produce data (blocked on evolution structured evidence)
- [ ] User-test produces data (evidence/user-test/ empty)
Status: BLOCKED — 2 prerequisites unresolved